Brice Marden Turned a Chinese Garden Into Pure Color

Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image (detail), Third Version, 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

Feature image: Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image (detail), Third Version, 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

Brice Marden Turned a Chinese Garden Into Pure Color

In classical China, scholars built gardens as small, composed landscapes for contemplation, and they kept eroded stones in their studios as stand-ins for mountains. Brice Marden (1938-2023), the American painter who made his name with monochrome panels in the 1960s, spent decades studying that tradition. In 2000, he began a series that turned the Chinese garden into pure color. Brice Marden's The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (2000-06), now at the Museum of Modern Art in New York, is its largest and most complete result.

Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version, 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version, 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

The Idea Behind the Title

Brice Marden came to the garden through calligraphy. After a 1984 exhibition of Japanese calligraphy in New York and a trip to Suzhou, China, he began painting looping lines based on the poems of Han Shan, a Tang dynasty poet known as Cold Mountain. He could not read Chinese, so he used the shape of the poems on the page, columns of characters in neat couplets, as a framework for his marks. The resulting Cold Mountain paintings (1988-91) debuted at the Dia Center for the Arts in 1991. Around the same time, Brice Marden began collecting Chinese scholars' rocks, the eroded stones that literati kept in their studios as miniature mountains. By 2000, his lines had loosened into long ribbons of paint, and he was ready to bring in color.

He explained the title in MoMA's audio guide for his 2006 retrospective, admitting, "It's a little pretentious, I acknowledge that." A friend who practiced numerology told him his number was six, so Brice Marden made the painting on six panels, each six feet tall and four feet wide, in six colors. Those colors are the spectrum minus indigo, which he dropped because he said he never understood it. "Plane image" was his own phrase for a painting whose image and flat surface fully merge, an idea he chased for his entire career.

Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (red panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (red panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (orange panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (orange panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

Compositional Analysis

The painting stretches six by twenty-four feet across six panels of oil on linen. From left to right, the backgrounds run red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet, the order of a rainbow. MoMA compares the long horizontal format to a classical Greek frieze, a form Brice Marden knew well from decades of summers on the Greek island of Hydra. He said his goal was to make six separate canvases read as one painting, and the identical panel sizes and unbroken run of background colors do most of that work.

Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (yellow panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (yellow panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (green panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (green panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

Each panel started as a single flat color. Brice Marden then painted looping lines on top in the other five colors, one at a time, always in spectrum order. On the red panel, the lines go orange, yellow, green, blue, and purple. On the orange panel, they go yellow, green, blue, purple, and red. Every panel holds all six colors, one as background and five as line.

The lines cross over and under one another so often that it becomes hard to tell which color sits on top, which gives the flat panels a sense of depth. Reviewing the 2006 retrospective for Frieze, the critic Mark Godfrey noted that in Brice Marden's line paintings one layer can seem to sit farther back, as if seen through fog, and that by this late period each band of color holds an even thickness. Those steady bands keep the surface calm while the overlaps keep it moving. Brice Marden painted the lines with brushes attached to long sticks, standing back so he could see the whole surface, then moved in close and worked the paint with a small knife until, as he later told his daughter Mirabelle in Interview magazine, every inch had been touched. That cycle of painting and scraping is a large part of why the series took six years.

Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (blue panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (blue panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (purple panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA
Brice Marden, The Propitious Garden of Plane Image, Third Version (purple panel), 2000-06, © 2026 Brice Marden via MoMA

The curator Gary Garrels, who organized the 2006 retrospective, described Brice Marden's work as fundamentally about light and color. Seen that way, the painting is a beam of light split into its parts across twenty-four feet, then woven back together inside each panel.

How It Came to MoMA

New paintings by Brice Marden were hard to buy in the early 2000s. According to Artnet News, his dealer, Matthew Marks Gallery, offered the collector and MoMA trustee Donald B. Marron first pick from the series if he also bought a major work for the museum. In 2006, Marron bought the Third Version as a gift to MoMA, credited today to Donald B. and Catherine C. Marron. It went straight into Brice Marden's retrospective, reportedly with its paint still wet.

The retrospective ran from October 29, 2006, to January 15, 2007, with more than fifty paintings and as many drawings, before traveling to the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art and the Hamburger Bahnhof in Berlin. The Second and Third Versions hung together in the final gallery. On the audio guide, Garrels introduced them as paintings just in from the studio and pointedly avoided calling them finished. Roberta Smith of The New York Times called the show "a quietly magnificent retrospective," and most critics agreed. The loudest dissent came from the blog Art Fag City, whose reviewer found the Third Version dull in person and better in reproduction.

Brice Marden, Event, 2004–2007, © Estate of Brice Marden / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York via Artnet News
Brice Marden, Event, 2004–2007, © Estate of Brice Marden / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York via Artnet News

The Rest of the Series

The series includes six works, a smaller First Version, the two large six-panel paintings, and three diptychs titled Event, Complements, and Extremes. Every panel apart from the First Version shares the same six-by-four-foot format. Brice Marden's Extremes (2004-05) went to the Centre Pompidou in Paris in 2006 as a gift of the Clarence Westbury Foundation. Marron kept Brice Marden's Complements (2004-07) for himself, choosing it at the artist's studio in Tivoli, New York, for a reported $3 million. After his death, it sold at Christie's in July 2020 for $30.9 million, a record for the artist at the time. In 2024, Christie's offered Event, a diptych even Garrels had never seen, with an estimate of $30 million to $50 million, then withdrew it on the night of the sale.

Brice Marden, Complements, 2004-07, © 2026 Estate of Brice Marden/Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York via Artnet News
Brice Marden, Complements, 2004-07, © 2026 Estate of Brice Marden/Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York via Artnet News

Brice Marden died at his home in Tivoli on August 9, 2023, at eighty-four. This fall, Gagosian's survey I Am Plane Image in New York, on view through December 12, 2026, includes the Second Version, and a detail of it fronts the fall issue of Gagosian Quarterly. The show is timed to the new Brice Marden: Catalogue Raisonné of Paintings, 1961-2023, edited by the scholar Tiffany Bell, which documents every painting in the series for the first time in one place. MoMA currently lists the Third Version as off view, so the Gagosian show is the best chance right now to stand in front of one of Brice Marden's two great spectrum gardens.


©ArtRKL® LLC 2021-2026. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ArtRKL® and its underscore design indicate trademarks of ArtRKL® LLC and its subsidiaries.

Back to blog

Categories

Recent Posts

Henri Matisse, La Danse (Dance II), 1910. © Succession H. Matisse / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York via Wikipedia/Public Domain

Henri Matisse's Dance and the Four Decades It K...

Matisse painted a ring of dancers for a Moscow staircase in 1910, then spent the rest of his career breaking that circle apart with paint, paper, and scissors.

Margaret Allen
Yoshitomo Nara, Dead Flower Title (detail), 1994 © Yoshitomo Nara via David Zwirner

Yoshitomo Nara's Defiant Children Were Always S...

A latchkey kid in rural Japan learned the world through American radio, then painted that solitude into the most recognizable children in contemporary art.

Taylor Grant
Unknown Hungarian master, Saint Martin and the Beggar (detail), c. 1490, Hungarian National Gallery, Budapest via Hungarian National Gallery

How Saint Martin's Divided Cloak Became an Art ...

Long before November 11 marked the end of a war, it belonged to a Roman soldier who cut his cloak in half, a gesture painters kept returning to.

Sebastian Moore