Van Gogh and Gauguin: The Tragic Feud and a Severed Ear

Feature image: Van Gogh, The Night Cafe, 1888 via Yale University Art Gallery/Wikipedia

In the autumn of 1888, Vincent van Gogh extended an invitation that would change the course of modern art. Living alone in the Provençal town of Arles, he envisioned the Yellow House not merely as a home but as the nucleus of a new artistic movement, an “atelier of the south” where painters could live, work, and inspire one another in collective harmony. Paul Gauguin, a rising figure in the Parisian avant-garde, stood at the center of this dream. Van Gogh, financially dependent on his younger brother Theo, begged him to subsidize Gauguin’s journey. The hope was simple yet profound: that companionship would remedy the crushing solitude that haunted him, and that collaboration might yield a new visual language for the modern world.

Gauguin, at the time both financially strapped and restless, agreed, though not without hesitation. The allure of free lodging and the romantic possibility of a sun-drenched studio retreat persuaded him, but he harbored doubts about Van Gogh’s temperament. He would later confess that he suspected, even before his arrival, that the venture was doomed.

For nine weeks, the two men lived and painted side by side in the Yellow House. From the outset, their temperaments clashed. Van Gogh, emotionally fragile and pathologically sincere, painted with feverish urgency. His canvases pulsed with inner turmoil, laid bare in expressive brushwork and vibrating, hallucinatory color. Gauguin, by contrast, was deliberate, cerebral, and steeped in Symbolist ideals. He viewed painting as a philosophical act, less about capturing the seen world and more about invoking the unseen. Van Gogh painted sunflowers in a blaze of cadmium yellow; Gauguin painted metaphor, memory, and myth.

Their conversations turned into confrontations. Art, for them, was not simply a vocation; it was belief, ideology, and identity. They quarreled over the role of memory versus observation, the use of color, the structure of composition, even domestic chores. Van Gogh, yearning for affirmation, was often deferential, yet Gauguin’s aloofness and growing irritation only deepened the chasm. What Van Gogh viewed as a passionate debate, Gauguin experienced as psychological suffocation. In Gauguin’s own words, the atmosphere in Arles became “electric,” thick with tension and dread.

The catastrophe came on the evening of December 23, 1888. The precise events of that night remain clouded by speculation, but most accounts, primarily Gauguin’s own, suggest a violent altercation. Gauguin claimed that Van Gogh pursued him with a razor blade before fleeing. What is indisputable is what followed: Van Gogh returned home, descended into psychosis, and severed part of his own left ear. He then wrapped it in newspaper and delivered it to a local brothel, offering it to a woman named Rachel with the cryptic instruction to “keep this object carefully.”

Gauguin left Arles the following morning without ever seeing Van Gogh again. He would later write of the episode with a mixture of horror and distance, but never without the sense that he had escaped something profoundly unstable. Van Gogh, meanwhile, was hospitalized in Arles, later transferred to the asylum at Saint-Rémy, and spent the remaining eighteen months of his life in a haze of creative brilliance and mental deterioration. He died by suicide in July 1890 at the age of thirty-seven.

In retrospect, the tragedy of their relationship is not merely psychological but also aesthetic. Both artists produced some of the most significant work of their careers during their brief cohabitation. Van Gogh painted The Bedroom, The Red Vineyard, and numerous sunflowers, infusing his canvases with both anguish and exultation. Gauguin completed The Painter of Sunflowers, a portrait of Van Gogh that reveals a mixture of admiration and foreboding, its yellow tones laced with madness. In their shared crucible, each pushed the other to new extremes, Van Gogh toward structure and symbolism, Gauguin toward emotional intensity and chromatic daring.

Yet the rupture between them is more than a biographical footnote. It speaks to the essential volatility of artistic collaboration when egos, ideals, and mental fragility collide. Their time in Arles represents both the possibility and impossibility of creative partnership, the dream of communion undone by the very individuality that makes artists great.

In the years following Van Gogh’s death, Gauguin mythologized their time together, casting himself as both witness and survivor of a genius unhinged. Meanwhile, Van Gogh’s letters, especially those to his brother Theo, offer a more poignant view: that of a man desperately seeking kinship and meaning through art, only to be met with silence and departure. These letters, some of the most intimate documents in art history, reveal a mind constantly negotiating the boundary between devotion and despair.

Today, the Yellow House no longer stands. But the legend it houses, of two titans colliding beneath its roof, endures. Their story has been adapted into novels, films, and countless academic texts, not simply because of its scandal or sorrow, but because it crystallizes something essential about the artistic life. Creation, for both Van Gogh and Gauguin, was never peaceful. It was a battleground of psyche and pigment, ideal and disillusionment. And that battle was waged side by side for one brief, terrible season in Arles.

©ArtRKL® LLC 2021-2025. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ArtRKL® and its underscore design indicate trademarks of ArtRKL® LLC and its subsidiaries.