How Artists Painted Nightmares Throughout Art History

Feature image: Anselm Kiefer, Sulamith, 1983 via SFMOMA

Nightmares have always fascinated artists. They blur the line between fear and fantasy, sleep and awareness. In art, they reveal the deepest corners of the human mind. Long before psychology and dream analysis, painters gave form to the invisible terrors that visited people at night. The idea of the nightmare was not only a subject of horror but also a way to explore imagination, vulnerability, and desire.

Among the artists who captured this tension was Nicolai Abraham Abildgaard, a Danish painter whose Nightmare from 1800 stands as one of the most mysterious and unsettling images in art history. His painting set the tone for an era that found beauty in fear. As we approach Halloween, let's take a look at the artists who painted nightmares throughout art history, and how they chose to do it.

In Abildgaard’s Nightmare, a woman lies asleep, her pale body half illuminated by a dim light. Atop her chest sits a dark, horned creature with glowing eyes. The figure stares out at the viewer, both playful and menacing. The woman’s stillness contrasts with the demon’s heavy presence, creating a scene filled with quiet tension.

The painting invites the viewer to wonder whether the creature is real or a projection of her dream. Abildgaard’s brushwork and shadowing make the room feel close and airless. His use of muted tones and dim light evokes a psychological weight. This image of sleep as both sanctuary and danger reflects the Romantic fascination with the mind’s hidden depths.

Abildgaard’s painting was influenced by Henry Fuseli’s The Nightmare (1781), one of the most famous depictions of the unconscious in Western art. In Fuseli’s version, a demonic incubus perches on a woman’s chest while a ghostly horse emerges from the shadows. The image is dramatic, theatrical, and full of movement. Abildgaard’s version is quieter but equally disturbing. He transforms Fuseli’s dream into something more internal.

Instead of the bold contrast of light and dark that Fuseli used, Abildgaard paints with restraint. His demon is more minor, almost human, and seems lost in thought. The focus shifts from external spectacle to psychological unease. By the turn of the nineteenth century, painters like Abildgaard began to see nightmares as part of human experience, not as punishments or supernatural invasions.

During the Romantic era, nightmares became symbols of the sublime. Artists used them to explore the beauty found in terror and the limits of human reason. Francisco Goya’s The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters (1799) captures this perfectly. In his etching, an artist slumps over his desk as dark creatures swirl behind him. The work reflects both creative imagination and the chaos that comes when reason sleeps.

For Romantic painters, fear was not only an emotion but also a path to truth. The storm, the shadow, the ghost, and the dream were all ways to reach the sublime. Abildgaard, Goya, and their contemporaries used darkness to reveal what light could not show. Their works transformed nightmares into reflections of human consciousness.

By the early twentieth century, artists no longer saw nightmares as threats. The rise of psychoanalysis and the writings of Sigmund Freud gave new meaning to dreams. Surrealist painters like Salvador Dalí, Max Ernst, and Dorothea Tanning embraced the logic of dreams as part of creative freedom.

Dalí’s The Dream Caused by the Flight of a Bee Around a Pomegranate a Second Before Awakening (1944) shows a sleeping woman surrounded by tigers, elephants, and fish floating in impossible space. The dream here is vibrant and alive, a theater of the mind. Dorothea Tanning’s Eine Kleine Nachtmusik (1943) transforms the nightmare into poetic imagery. Two girls stand in a hallway under a surreal light, surrounded by giant sunflower petals. The scene feels quiet yet charged with meaning.

For the Surrealists, nightmares were not frightening visions but expressions of the subconscious. They revealed desires, fears, and memories that shape daily life. Painters explored them as a kind of truth-telling, a mirror to the mind’s secret language.

As modern art developed, nightmares became more psychological than mythological. Artists like Francis Bacon and Anselm Kiefer explored the inner darkness of human experience. Bacon’s Study after Velázquez’s Portrait of Pope Innocent X (1953) captures pure psychological torment. The screaming figure appears trapped in his own mind, surrounded by invisible walls of anguish.

Kiefer’s vast and textured canvases evoke historical trauma and collective memory. His works often feel like nightmares of history, where the past seeps into the present. These artists used the imagery of fear not to shock but to understand. The nightmare became a symbol of human resilience, a way to express what words cannot.

Every nightmare begins as a loss of control. In sleep, the conscious mind disappears, and images move without logic. For an artist, this state can become a source of invention. Nightmares open a space where new forms appear, unfiltered by reason. They reveal emotions that cannot exist in daylight. What begins as fear becomes a form of creation.

Throughout history, painters have used nightmares to stretch imagination. The dark room, the monster, the fall, and the distorted face all carry the energy of discovery. These images are not only records of fear but also experiments with vision. Abildgaard’s demon pressing on the dreamer’s chest is both a symbol of terror and an allegory of artistic pressure. To paint a nightmare is to give form to what the mind resists.

Modern neuroscience describes dreams as the brain’s rehearsal for emotion. Artists understood this long before science did. They turned their nightmares into studies of perception, color, and the anatomy of thought. Surrealists called this process “automatic creation.” Contemporary artists still follow the same impulse. The nightmare remains a tool for accessing invention, a rehearsal of chaos that allows for beauty.

Seen this way, nightmares in art are not about darkness alone. They are about transformation. The image that terrifies can also heal, reveal, or clarify. It allows artists and viewers to meet fear directly and find shape in uncertainty. In this sense, the nightmare becomes not a vision of despair but a map of imagination itself.

©ArtRKL® LLC 2021-2025. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ArtRKL® and its underscore design indicate trademarks of ArtRKL® LLC and its subsidiaries.